Doing Business - How Useful Are These Indicators Anyway?

This was the big question during a sometimes heated panel discussion I recently attended in Miami. With a lawyer, an investor, and a government official present, one can imagine that the views varied. Juan Pablo Capello from Greenberg Traurig, who has advised many international investors, saw the indicators as quite limited as they focus mostly on local, small and medium size enterprises. In his view, sovereign ratings and legal certainly matter much more for foreign investors. Luis Manuel Kolster from GM countered that actually investors do look at tax rates and regulatory burden, but the decision to invest is also foremost driven by market size and cost. What I found most interesting was the government perspective, or should I say reformer perspective, by Liliana Rojas from the Colombian Ministry of Commerce. At the end of the day, it is governments that create and shape the regulatory environment for businesses. So, are they doing this in the sole hope of attracting sudden large foreign investment? She saw the indicators and rankings as a rather useful tool for benchmarking, informing reform agendas and tracking progress. The goal of these reforms? Promote and support local businesses and, in this way, aid job creation and growth. In the end, all participants agreed that, particularly nowadays, this is an important objective to have.